Public Infrastructure Investment and the Efficiency Paradox: Empirical Evidence From Selected Asian Economies

Abstract

This study empirically examines the efficiency paradox of public infrastructure investment across eight South and Southeast Asian economies using panel data over the period 1996 to 2019. The efficiency paradox, as formalized by Berg et al. (2018), posits that Low Efficiency Countries (LECs) may derive paradoxically higher long-run growth returns from public investment than High Efficiency Countries (HECs) when public and private capital are complements rather than substitutes. Public investment efficiency coefficients are estimated using the law of motion for public capital within a Fixed Effects framework, while the complementarity between public and private capital is examined through a log-linearized interaction framework motivated by the nested CES production structure of Sato (1967), with the interaction term capturing the conditional marginal effect of public capital on output given the level of private capital.

Estimated efficiency coefficients reveal significant cross-country heterogeneity, ranging from 42 percent in Sri Lanka and 47 percent in Pakistan to 86 percent in India and 78 percent in Malaysia. Government investment flows exert a positive and significant short-run effect on GDP per capita, with a long-run multiplier of 0.604, while accumulated public capital stock exhibits negative or insignificant long-run coefficient, a flow-stock duality broadly consistent with the efficiency paradox. The interaction between public and private capital is positive but statistically insignificant, providing directional evidence of complementarity. Institutional quality and human capital exhibit weak moderating effects, consistent with institutional threshold effects in the regional context. Trade openness emerges as the most robust and consistently positive determinant of growth across all specifications. The findings suggest that sustained public investment commitments, complemented by improvements in public investment management capacity at the planning, procurement, and implementation stages, are essential for translating infrastructure spending into productive long-run capital accumulation.

Akbar Khan

Meta Data

Author: Akbar Khan
Supervisor:Haider Ali
Internal Examiner: Iftikhar Ahmad
External Examiner: Hassan Muhammad Mohsin
Keywords : Economic Growth, Efficiency Paradox, Public Infrastructure Investment, Public Investment Efficiency, Public-Private Capital stock Complementarity, South and Southeast Asia

Related Thesis​